Survival Shotgun Part 2: Choosing Gauge and Type

Survival Shotgun Gauge and Type

If you are new to shotguns understanding what type of gun to buy and which gauge to choose for your survival needs can be difficult. Continuing the Survival Shotgun series, here is a basic rundown of the types and sizes of shotguns you should consider for your survival gear.

This article is Part 2 in a series of guest posts on the Survival Shotgun by mr. Smashy (Flickr) Part 1 and Part 3

The basic operation of a shotgun is to fire a dose of round lead balls (shot) down a smooth bore barrel.  Shotguns existed before rifles and pistols, and the concept of blasting shot down a smooth barrel may extend all the way back to ancient China.  Modern Man’s innovation has managed to stuff all sorts of things into a shotgun shell, but the basic operation still remains.

Understanding Gauge

Mossberg M500SPShotguns barrels are typically chambered in gauges, not calibers.  A gauge is the number of lead balls it takes to roll down the barrel to make a pound.  If you’re wondering why that sounds crazy, it’s an imperial measurement created by the English, and they tend to over-complicate things.  But it does explain why a 12 gauge has a larger tube than a 20 gauge.  The most common chamberings for shotguns are 10, 12, 16, and 20 gauge.  There is also .410 bore, which is a newer size based on the .45 Colt.  It’s an American invention and is not a true gauge.

Choosing a Gauge

Why is this important?  You need to pick a gauge (or bore) that is suitable for your stature or needs.  Recoil is usually the determining factor, but for the prepper you want to also consider availability.  Up to 50% of shotguns sold in America are 12 gauge.  You will simply have an easier time finding ammunition for a 12 gauge.

If you cannot handle the recoil of a 12 gauge, then go with 20 if possible.  If you cannot deal with the recoil of a 20 gauge then .410 bore is your last resort.  Other gauges Survival Shotgunlike 10 and 16 are available but too rare for a prepper to consider seriously; you are not going to find 16 gauge ammo on the shelf at a superstore.

For the sake of brevity and to show how versatile the shotgun is, I will stick to 12 gauge for the majority of this series.  Birdshot, slugs, and buckshot ammunition are available in 20 gauge.  Birdshot and buckshot are available in .410, but you are getting three pellets of 000 buck per shell for the buckshot, versus a 12 gauge 000 load which holds 10 pellets or more.  There are also slugs available for .410, usually weighing 1/4 an ounce versus a standard 1 ounce slug in 12 gauge.  .410 slug ammunition is also extremely hard to find unless it’s deer season in a shotgun hunting state.

Type of Shotgun

For most preppers, the standard survival shotgun is going to be a 12 gauge pump shotgun; readily available at your local superstore.  Semi-auto shotguns are great, and usually a joy to shoot, but there are issues that should be considered.

Mossberg M500SPSemi-autos cost more, usually starting at double the cost of a pump and up.  Some of the cheaper models have reliability and quality issues.  Parts can and do get worn out more frequently.  Some autoloaders will only feed reliably with certain kinds of ammunition, like full power loads.

Barring oddball rounds like the Aquila mini-shells, a pump action gun will cycle any load you feed it because of the manual loading process, including reduced recoil loads, light birdshot, and less lethal ammo with no projectile.  Autoloaders rely on either recoil or gas to operate the action.

Each has it’s advantages, but both systems require more preventative maintenance and cleaning for reliable performance.  What a prepper is looking for in the survival toolkit is something cheap, reliable, and versatile.  And that is the 12 gauge pump action shotgun.

Questions

If you have questions, or need help choosing a gun, ask here and we will do our best to point you in the right direction.

Part 3

Part 3 of the Survival Shotgun series by mr. Smashy covers Choosing Your Gun

Visit Our New Survival Gear Store – Forge Survival Supply

Photo by: mr. smashy

{ 36 comments… read them below or add one }

JonnyJ July 29, 2010 at 3:26 pm

I own a 12 ga. mossberg 500 pistol grip with an 181/2" barrel, Although it's not really for hunting game as much as home defense, I still have #8 bird shot loaded to go. I personally would not enjoy a blast from this behemoth,And any intruder on the receiving end would certainely not say Sir may I have another. I enjoy your site and there are many good tips in here.Thank you.

Reply

Justin August 26, 2010 at 3:46 pm

#8 is so small and is wayyyyy less than ideal for home defense.
Buy some buckshot

Reply

real world survival November 28, 2010 at 5:23 pm

Hey you can have a mossberg 500, a high end remington tactical 870, or a junker charles daly pump, but if you don't have the right ammo you put yourself and your family at risk, bottom line. It's not a Behemoth unless you load it with the propper ammo.The 00buck or slug would be the best, but a couple sizes smaller would be acceptable. Law enforcement won't use anything less than #4 but usually stick with 00buck. the ARMY and MARINES use 00buck. My gun is a remington 870 police magnum 8 shot, it's the parkerized version of the marine magnum. I only have three loads for it: Remington slugs, rem. 00buck, and rem. 00buck Magnum 3". load it properly and sleep alittle more sound.

Reply

RudeBoy_UrbSurv August 12, 2010 at 10:11 pm

I own a Remington 870 full tactical model with a Spec Ops recoil reducing AR style stock and Surefire forend. The Spec Ops stock allows shooters of different statures and the recoil sensitive to fire the 12 ga more comfortably. I think the 12 ga is probably the single most important firearm a survival minded person can own. Game loads for hunting, buck for close defense, and slugs for intermediate to long ranges (surprisingly accurate through a smooth bore) make for a must have weapon. Affordable, adaptable, and available.

Reply

W.T. September 23, 2010 at 8:16 pm

A "survival shotgun"…hmmm. I own the Remington model 10 12 gauge my grand dad used between 1910 and 1920 along the South Texas border to ward off bandits (Mexican and Texan) and other scoundrels that wandered through the ranch in pursuit of no good. Just a shotgun, pump, 30 inch barrel, full choke. Used if for geese too when they migrated south. Shot a Texas Ranger (woops) one afternoon who rode up to the ranch drunk on his horse shooting his gun at a couple of my grand dad's vaqueros. Blasted the idiot off his horse, dug a hole and planted him. So much for the Texas Rangers. But it was just a shotgun. Didn't have the word "survival" or "tactical" or any of that nonsense attached to it. Do you get my drift? Grand dad finally retired the gun after Mexico settled down and took to his Winchester 1903 .22 auto to shoot everything from javelina, deer, coyotes, rattlesnakes, and whatever else nasty came along. I have that rifle too in my vault. Funny how those old timers got along just fine without ever knowing they didn't own "tactical" or "survival" guns. Imagine that.

Reply

bigbob25060 November 16, 2010 at 5:55 pm

Fantastic, what an ideal post. We kinda do have a tendency to get hung up on titles huh?
I have a couple of 870's and an 1100 that are just shotguns. I'm suposin' I can use them for survival stuff too tho huh. :)

Reply

real world survival November 28, 2010 at 5:47 pm

keep the ignorance to a minimum, please. Some people are trying to learn and some of us are trying to teach them. An example for you, try to navigate corners with pappys 30" barrel around a corner in a dark house and you will fall victim to a gun grab and probably catch bullet in the face or abdomen, off course you'll be dead while the intrudder rapes your loved ones. As I will state I tell people to buy the best they can afford, and make due. If your grandfathers shotgun is all you have make due I hope no harm befalls you. But there are much better and safer options for people out there.

Reply

Genghis October 31, 2010 at 4:18 pm

I would prefer a Winchester 1300HD 8 rd.+1. This weapon is well used around the world, even though it is not manufactured any longer. But, by adding a stock selve to the weapon of 5 or 6 rds. your firing capacity is larger. Also by adding the same seleve to your arms one ea. you now have 10-12 rds. extra. , plus bandoliers of 50 rds. now you are set to defend. I also use 40 cal. hand gun, it has a little more punch w/5 extra clips.

Reply

Scott November 24, 2010 at 6:39 am

Ease of finding replacement parts, common availability of ammunition, and simple reliability led me to my purchase of a Mossberg 500A with an 18 1/2 inch barrel and 7 round capacity.Being modular I added a forward pistol grip, tactical stock (solid to shoulder w/ pistol grip) and
a “Side Saddle” 6 round carrier on side opposite the ejector. I’ve experimented with the different setups of pistol grips and stocks, and found this works best for me. Oh, yeah I should clarify thaat this is my personal protection firearm, but use a bolt-action SMLE and bolt action .410 Savage for putting food on the table. Personal survival is all about personal preference though, so don’t be afraid of investing money into your own protection. I have, and I feel great about it. And don’t let people try to brow beat you into thinking only criminals own guns. Those people are going to be the ones wanting to follow you and freeload off your well stocked supplies when TSHTF.

Reply

l. Massie December 1, 2010 at 1:48 am

I've wondered why survival to a lot of guys means defending the kin folk against mutant zombie bickers or some other fantasy involving heroic stands against incredible odds. It's I suppose nice to have 8 rounds you can jack through but it's the first one that counts. It's also real important to have it kind of like nice and handy rather than having a safe queen. My go to gun is a H&R 12 ga. single, 3" #4 in the spout and a few more on the stock. Real handy with that gun. Keep it in the kitchen closet. Got another at the cabin with a "survival" stock. It's full of survival goodies and may be a good idea. Not real sure about that yet. Still with the sling it goes real fine with a pack tramping through the woods. It's light enough that don't know it's there, unlike those street sweepers mentioned above. Cps might like those, but they got to look tough and important and don't have to walk/trot/run more than 100' in any given year.
Anyway, when the bear's in the garage, my trusty little single is what gets pointed at it. It is also what I'd chose as perfect survival gun. As far as the MZB are concerned, I figure I'd hear/smell then a long way off and go the other way (always did like Tunnel in the Sky by Bob Heinlein).

Reply

l. Massie December 1, 2010 at 1:48 am

I've wondered why survival to a lot of guys means defending the kin folk against mutant zombie bickers or some other fantasy involving heroic stands against incredible odds. It's I suppose nice to have 8 rounds you can jack through but it's the first one that counts. It's also real important to have it kind of like nice and handy rather than having a safe queen. My go to gun is a H&R 12 ga. single, 3" #4 in the spout and a few more on the stock. Real handy with that gun. Keep it in the kitchen closet. Got another at the cabin with a "survival" stock. It's full of survival goodies and may be a good idea. Not real sure about that yet. Still with the sling it goes real fine with a pack tramping through the woods. It's light enough that don't know it's there, unlike those street sweepers mentioned above. Cps might like those, but they got to look tough and important and don't have to walk/trot/run more than 100' in any given year.
Anyway, when the bear's in the garage, my trusty little single is what gets pointed at it. It is also what I'd chose as perfect survival gun. As far as the MZB are concerned, I figure I'd hear/smell then a long way off and go the other way (always did like Tunnel in the Sky by Bob Heinlein).

Reply

matt December 16, 2010 at 2:43 am

I am looking at getting a remington 870 aow with a 14 in barrel with the tax stamp and everything legal just so there is no confusion. What do you guys think about that? I read all the posts here and sounds like a very knowledgeable group of folks any adivse you guys can give me would be greatly appreciated

Reply

hux February 14, 2011 at 3:54 am

My second post – but it’s very quiet here …… hope some of you guys are still reading from time-2-time.

This has been very interesting – both the technical article and the commentary.

I don’t want to throw any cold water on anyone’s ideas, but in my “cut-lunch-commando” days of National Military Service in the land of Oz (Downunder), I was used as a “Range Safety Officer” because of my supposed expert explosives knowledge and the clearest memory is of the “hero” types who tended to crack when it got “real” or realistic.

I lost count of the number of guys who dropped grenades on the training mound when they heard the fuse ignite. (They thought they were dummies).

So, my thoughts are that at the end of the day, in a real situation, things can be very different.

I’ve never been shot at, but I do know it would make a helluva difference if you knew the target could shoot back. Don’t think there would be many deer hunters if the deer were armed! :-)

The shotgun therefore, in my humble opinion, would have to be the best all round choice.

Much harder to miss.

Much less to go wrong.

Much easier to service.

Easier to make your own powder and shot.

AND much more scary if you had to confront one.

Cheers from Oz!

Reply

CaptBart August 11, 2011 at 1:40 pm

Agree with everything except the "harder to miss". At close combat ranges the pattern is somewhere between 2 and 3.5 inches. A pattern that tight can easily miss at oh-dark-thirty when fine motor skills no longer exist. You are quite right that "things can be very different". When lead is going BOTH ways the attention is certainly more 'focused' shall we say and a miss is much more probable, especially if someone has bought into the "scatter gun that takes out the entire wall" nonsense. thanks for the comments.

Reply

Brianna March 28, 2012 at 8:12 pm

Now wait i don't mean to sound like a green horn (i am) but i was under the impression that there was at least a type of ammo that when placed into a gun and then fired went in all directions(though short was the range of the bullets) it was enough to leave a sizable hole. Though not necessarily in a wall par-say but in a body yes.
If my impression was wrong sorry but do understand i'll never know until i ask. Don't take my head off i'm just trying to learn. My family thinks I'm weird but i just say that i don't want to be unprepared if the need to be arrises. Is it so bad? No. I think not.

Reply

CaptBart March 29, 2012 at 9:07 am

No, problem; we were all green at some point and after 40+ years a lot of folks think I am weird. Don't take it personally that you recognize the need to care for yourself and they don't. They're wrong and you're not.

Hollywood and TV have formed the myth of the gun that will 'take out the back wall'. Even a short barreled 'Coach Gun' (double barrel, 18 inches in length) 12 gauge has a fairly tight pattern out to 15 feet or so. Go to a range and shoot at targets at 10, and 15 to 30 feet and you'll see what I mean. 3.5 inches of shot can gut someone like a catfish but you have to actually hit them. It is a BIG hole but remember, too much spread and you can miss the target. My coach gun is not a good hunting weapon because at 30 yards I might miss a bird because all the shot expanded around it leaving a center void; I hit center of aim on the bird but no pellets were still in the center. Remember that most close quarters, home defense shooting occurs inside of 10 feet. A shot gun has limited pellets so in order to get sufficient lead into a target at range, the barrel tends to keep the pellets fairly close. The idea is that it is supposed to spread over distance to increase your chances but beyond a certain point, the shot is so thinly spread that hitting or missing is by chance. Up close, the shot is dense enough to ensure a LOT of damage but the spread doesn't go wide enough to make up for a lousy aim. It is a function of the gun, not the ammo really. The shorter the barrel, the wider the pattern. Most states limit it to around 18 inches and that works out to about 3.5 inches at 10 feet on most gun/ammo combinations.
Did this help?

Reply

nerdyadventurer February 17, 2011 at 8:06 am

The only gun I currently own is a 12 gauge. My grandfather bought it for me as a 12th birthday present. I absolutely love the thing, very simple no extras gun. And I don’t think that the armed prowler that my mom put a round of buckshot in with it cared that it was ‘just a plain old hunting gun’. :) Maybe I’m just sentimental.

Reply

CaptBart August 11, 2011 at 1:45 pm

I have a rather sentimental attachment to things that work well. You have a weapon that worked as needed, when needed. You can't ask more than that from anything. Same reason I'm sentimental about the Colt 1911 and don't much care for the M16 platform. I trust what has worked and, in the world of firearms, I rarely, if ever, give a second chance to what did not work. Congratulations on owning a fine weapon.

Reply

Ben228 July 15, 2011 at 2:47 am

Recently upgraded my Mossberg 500 to 7+1 and am looking at a collapsible stock (shock asorbing). My major concern is California’s “menacing” restrictions. The goal being not being in jail when TSHTF. The thread had a mention of a shock absorbing stock is intreicing but not if it gets me charged with a felony and disarms me.

Other then that the upgrade has given me a shotty with a 20″ barrel and the 00 buck pattern that is better. (tighter a yard or two further out)

Reply

Tommy July 26, 2011 at 7:04 pm

Sounds like a lot of good posts, i love my 20 ga mossy. I bought it in the 80's with a pistol grip, but since i have put on a full stock, all i'm going to add is an inexpensive tack lite. Hopefully i will only have to shoot the intruder with the light. I like the 20 ga. 25% less energy then the 12 ga. but 50- 60% less recoil. No matter what shot gun you have it's a good grab in a bad situation…

Reply

Be nice September 24, 2011 at 4:04 pm

You're a dick for that.

Reply

Guest October 28, 2011 at 8:07 am

Good post! I have a question though. I haven't used shotguns all that much, last time I believe was 4 or 5 years ago; Should I go with a 20 gauge or a 12 gauge? I can easily handle recoil from a 20 gauge, but I'm concerned with the 12 gauge recoil, It only takes 2 or 3 shots before I'm sore from shooting it. Should I opt to buy a 12 gauge and just practice with it to toughen me up or should I stick with 20 gauge? Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!

P.S. If it helps at all, I'm more worried about the amount of time I'd have to use it if SHTF. I'd rather be prepared to protect my own with a 20 gauge then thinking I'm safe with a 12 gauge and using it more than I thought.

Reply

CaptBart November 16, 2011 at 3:12 pm

Guest,
In my not so humble opinion you answered your own question with "…but I'm concerned with the 12 gauge recoil…". You want a weapon you are absolutely comfortable with if you are going to be playing "you bet your life" with it. Inside of 50 feet or so, without instruments or the Coroner telling you, you'd be hard pressed to tell if a BG had gotten hit by a 12 or a 20. If you are recoil sensitive (I'm getting that way as I age; if I had it to do again, I'd have 20's) the 12 could lead to you flinching and a miss while a 20 would get a hit. YOU CAN NOT MISS FAST ENOUGH OR WITH A BIG ENOUGH GUN TO WIN A GUN FIGHT! Only hits count. If you don't trust a gun, don't think it is reliable, don't like to shoot it, heck, if you just don't like it period, get rid of it and get something you are comfortable with. There are no prizes for shooting the biggest cannon. There are only prizes for staying alive.
A 20 (or a .410 for that matter) will feed a family, stop a rabid animal, repel an intruder. So will a 12. Get the one you will practice with and can consistently shoot well. Anything else is a waste of money and could cost you your life or the lives of your loved ones. There is nothing on this planet that a 12 GA will stop/kill that a 20 GA will not also stop/kill. Out at 50 to 100 yards, there may be some differences that are noticeable against hard targets, but in close, nothing to be concerned with. Besides that, if you don't get used to the greater recoil, then what? Ammo is more readily available for the 12 than the 20 perhaps but both are available and relatively cheap so I don't think that is a deal breaker.
As I said, just my not so humble opinion, but in this case, I'm very right!

Reply

Reinhold December 16, 2011 at 10:45 pm

How about the Kel-Tec KSG:
"The KSG weighs 6.9lbs and is as compact as legally possible with a 26.1" overall length and an 18.5" cylinder bore barrel. Even with this compact size, the internal dual tube magazines hold an impressive 6 rounds of 12 gage 3" shells each, for a total capacity of 6+6+1 (7 per tube if using 2-3/4" shells). "
http://www.keltecweapons.com/news/preview-kel-tec…

Reply

corwin46 March 19, 2012 at 8:32 pm

This is a great offensive and defensive weapon but I wouldn't consider it a survival gun. I don't think it would hunt very well but it is scary enough to make a lot of BG's want to leave you alone.

Reply

mack February 26, 2012 at 4:30 pm

I wonder if that single will do any good when you are trying to protect your supplies from a dude with a pump. “Oh hold on let me reload”.

Reply

Skulp March 18, 2012 at 11:31 am

great posts from everyone! I sleep soundly at night with a 12ga remington 870 beside my bed. it has a flashlight attached to it and an extended magazine tube. if I have to bug out I will attach the single point sling.
That said, none of it matters if I dont wake up in the middle of the night with the missus, and practice clearing my house. Once a quarter or so.
if you don’t hit with your first shot you probably won’t hit at all. if you start with a very large guage and work your way down lesser guages dont feel as rough

Reply

ThomasC. March 28, 2012 at 8:38 am

Remember the ammo you use should be consistant with what you want it to do. Ballistically speeking, #1 buck is the best manstopper. NOT 00. Not so say that 00 won't work as a man stopper I'm sure it does. If you want to ake small game, use game loads. If you are using slugs for hunting know that a slug out of a 20ga. has almost 2 times the effective range of a slug out of a 12ga.

Reply

Brianna March 28, 2012 at 7:46 pm

I need a survival gun that is best for a young girl. its meant for me to use, I'm 17 about to be 18 so age limits is important also this gun(don't really care if its a handgun or a rifle or whatever) needs to be versile(sp?) and be of use in hunting, offense, and deffense. also this will be adding to my get out of dodge bag/ hiking bag it would be useful if i could strap it to a leg(or something) or fit comfortably in a bag. If you could please answer with good info it would be very useful.

Reply

jacob April 10, 2012 at 2:02 pm

You want a 4″ inch barreled .357 magnum double action revolver. powerefull enough for deer and people. Compact enough to wear in a holster comfortably. It also has the ability to shoot .38 special ammo wich has less recoil since you are probably new to shooting. If i could only have one gun thats what i would have. They are also generally accurate and easy to use. Also they are generally more reliable than semi-auto pistols.

Reply

Instructor April 12, 2012 at 3:49 am

You must be 21 in order to own a handgun. Find a shotgun that you can handle comfortably. Even if it's a .410. I imagine a 20 gauge might work for you. Ask people you know that have shotguns or find a local range that rents guns so you can try before you buy. Also start saving up for that pistol for your 21st birthday.

Reply

Mr. T March 9, 2011 at 3:39 pm

or stack it (1)#8, (3) 00 buck, (2) slugs

Reply

CaptBart August 11, 2011 at 1:22 pm

I've said elsewhere and will say here; if you are faced with MZB hordes unless you have full auto, belt fed (think M2 or M60) you loose.The most reliable gun in the world is a single shot – a double is just two singles on one stock (part of why I like them so much) and there is NO second shot as fast as from a double which is part of why double rifles are/were so popular with professional hunters. It is also hard for a DA to argue that your single is a "man killing super weapon".

Reply

Jengo October 30, 2011 at 4:00 pm

They got along just fine with donkeys, too, before cars.

Reply

Guest April 13, 2012 at 1:27 pm

I'm not sure how old these posts are,but I must respectfully disagree with the above replies. Before the flaming begins, you should know that I have served on multiple air-ambulance tours to Iraq and have been an advanced EMT as a civilian for several years now. I have seen and treated (usually unsuccesfully) close range shotgun wounds. At typical home defense ranges, the shot has not traveled enough distance to expand significantly, and the victim is generally left with a hole the size of a fifty cent piece into which all of the shot and even the wad has penetrated.

Reply

Guest April 13, 2012 at 1:27 pm

In cases in which bird shot is used, there is generally not an exit wound. These are generally the worst, as all of the energy is unloaded into the victims body instead of exiting from the other side. That equals scrambled organs and death. Some will also say, "birdshot doesn't penetrate heavy clothing." Also false. I responded to a scene in which a man was shot in the back with 20 guage bird-shot while hunting in the winter. The shot and wad penetrated several layers of clothing (carhartts) and a pair of ribs, and still had plenty of energy to cause massive destruction of his internal organs. I'm not saying buckshot is less effective. It isn't, but use your setup in the home with confidence unless you live in a home with rooms that are 40X40 or if you have excessively long hallways. I would suggest swapping that pistol grip with a regular old shoulder stock or shoulder stock with a pistol grip. It may not look as cool, but being able to look down your sights, even with a shotgun, will improve your hit probability significantly.

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 3 trackbacks }